The Theory That Changed How We Understand Entrepreneurship

”The underlying idea is that when the future is difficult to predict, entrepreneurs can still influence how it unfolds.”

In a nutshell

Effectuation theory challenges the assumption that entrepreneurship begins with a clear goal and a carefully calculated plan. Introduced by Saras Sarasvathy in 2001, it explains how entrepreneurs can create opportunities by starting with what they have, working with others and shaping an uncertain future through their actions.

In a Bigger Nutshell

Imagine you’re starting a business. What’s the first thing you’re supposed to do? Identify an opportunity, maybe? Research the market? Write a business plan? Figure out who your customers are, what they want, and how much they’re willing to pay?

There’s nothing inherently wrong with any of these approaches, but they share one rather significant assumption: that you already know what you’re trying to achieve. You might not know exactly how to get there, but at least there’s a destination.

Now imagine that you don’t have one. Perhaps you have some skills, a few useful contacts and a vague ambition to start something. Or perhaps you’re developing a product for a market that doesn’t exist yet. How exactly are you supposed to research the demand for something nobody has ever encountered?

This was the problem that researcher Saras Sarasvathy set out to address in her influential 2001 paper. Traditional theories of business decision-making, she argued, were remarkably good at explaining how people make decisions within existing markets and organisations – but they had considerably less to say about how those markets and organisations came into existence in the first place.

Her answer was a theory called effectuation, and it challenged some of the most fundamental assumptions about how entrepreneurs think and act.

Research behind this article

Sarasvathy (2001) The original theory of causation and effectuation.
journals.aom.org
Dew et al. (2009) Empirical comparison of expert entrepreneurs and MBA students.
sciencedirect.com
Read, Song & Smit (2009) Meta-analysis connecting effectuation-related behaviours with venture performance.
sciencedirect.com

Chandler et al. (2011) Development and validation of measures for studying causation and effectuation.
sciencedirect.com
Smolka et al. (2018) Evidence that causation and effectuation can complement one another.
journals.sagepub.com
Kitching & Rouse (2020)Criticism of the theory’s treatment of social and structural influences.
journals.sagepub.com

The impact of decision-making styles on firm performance (2022) Larger meta-analysis of relationships between decision-making approaches and business performance. sciencedirect.com

What It Is

To explain effectuation, Sarasvathy introduced this wonderfully simple analogy:

Imagine a chef who’s been asked to prepare a particular dish. They find a recipe, gather the necessary ingredients and get to work. The outcome is already decided, and the challenge is figuring out how to achieve it.

Now imagine another chef who’s simply told to make something with whatever is in the kitchen. They open the fridge, look at the ingredients and decide what they could make.

The first chef is using what Sarasvathy calls causal reasoning. The second is using effectual reasoning.

In entrepreneurship, causal reasoning means beginning with a predetermined goal and identifying the resources and actions required to achieve it. Effectual reasoning, on the other hand, begins with the resources available and considers the different outcomes that could be created from them.

For example, someone determined to open a restaurant might research locations, identify target customers, develop a menu and seek investment. Someone thinking effectually might begin by cooking lunches for friends, discover that local offices are interested in catering, and eventually build a business they hadn’t originally considered.

In other words, the entrepreneur’s goals can change as the business develops. New partners, resources and unexpected events can introduce possibilities that weren’t apparent at the beginning. The underlying idea is that when the future is difficult to predict, entrepreneurs can still influence how it unfolds.

How It Works

So how does this actually work in practice? Over time, Sarasvathy and other researchers developed five principles of effectuation that help explain how entrepreneurs can make progress when they don’t know what the future holds.

The first is called Bird in Hand, and it starts with three questions: Who am I? What do I know? And whom do I know? The answers give entrepreneurs something to work with, even when they have no particular business idea in mind. And because everyone has different skills, experiences and connections, these same questions can lead to entirely different ventures.

Then there’s Affordable Loss, which challenges another familiar assumption about business decisions. Instead of trying to calculate how much an opportunity might eventually earn, entrepreneurs consider how much they’re willing and able to lose pursuing it. For example, someone might spend a few hundred pounds testing a product before investing thousands in producing it. If it works, they can take the next step. If it doesn’t, they can try something else without having lost everything. This makes it possible to experiment without having to know in advance whether an idea will succeed.

This is also where Sarasvathy makes a particularly interesting point about the value of not knowing. She quotes scientist Michael Polanyi, who reflected that he might never have developed one of his theories in physics if he’d known more about the research that came before it. At the time, other scientists had already come up with reasons why his idea wouldn’t work. But because Polanyi wasn’t aware of these objections, he pursued it anyway – and eventually proved them wrong. Sarasvathy uses this example to question the assumption that having more information always leads to better decisions. Sometimes, knowing all the reasons something supposedly won’t work might stop us from discovering that it actually could.

Of course, entrepreneurs can’t create everything on their own. The Crazy Quilt principle is about finding people who are willing to get involved and contribute something to the venture. A customer who agrees to place an order, for example, gives the entrepreneur something much more concrete to work with than a prediction about potential customers. Partners might also bring money, knowledge or connections that make new things possible. And as more people get involved, they help shape what the business becomes.

Which brings us to Lemonade, the principle of making use of unexpected developments. An entrepreneur might discover that customers are interested in an entirely different product from the one they intended to sell. Instead of sticking to the original plan, they can explore where that unexpected interest might lead.

All of this comes together in the fifth principle, Pilot in the Plane, which captures the underlying logic of effectuation. To explain it, Sarasvathy uses an example involving a game of chance. Imagine there’s a container filled with red and green balls, and you win a prize if you draw a red one. The conventional approach would be to work out how many red balls are in the container so you can calculate your chances of winning.

But what if you could add your own red balls? Or persuade other people to add theirs? You wouldn’t need to know your chances of winning at the beginning, because you could improve them yourself. And if you could only get hold of green balls, you might even create a new game where green balls win instead.

That’s the idea behind effectuation’s emphasis on control. Entrepreneurs can influence what happens through their own actions and the people they work with, and the more they can influence, the less they need to rely on accurate predictions.

Sarasvathy’s original paper was theoretical, but the decades of research that followed have provided considerable support for her ideas. Studies have found that experienced entrepreneurs often use effectual reasoning, and that effectual behaviours are associated with better business performance. One large study involving more than 1,400 entrepreneurs across 25 countries also found that businesses performed particularly well when entrepreneurs combined effectuation with traditional planning.

So, the evidence suggests that effectuation can be useful, but there’s no reason to throw out the business plan just yet. Even Sarasvathy herself argued that both approaches have their place.

There are criticisms, though, worth taking seriously. Some researchers argue that while effectuation helps explain how entrepreneurs make decisions, it doesn’t fully explain why some people are able to start businesses while others aren’t. After all, someone with money, connections and a good education has a very different starting point from someone without them. Both might use effectuation, but their chances of succeeding can still be very different.

For entrepreneurship educators, perhaps the most important lesson is that opportunities don’t always exist before someone decides to pursue them. Sometimes, they emerge through the process of trying things out, meeting people and discovering what’s possible.

And that’s something students can practise. They can start with the resources they already have, test ideas without risking everything, involve others and learn from unexpected results. Effectuation gives them a way to make decisions even when they don’t have enough information to know which decision will turn out to be the right one.

More than two decades after its introduction, effectuation remains one of the most influential theories in entrepreneurship education. Sarasvathy’s central argument is still a useful reminder that businesses, markets and opportunities have to come from somewhere, and that the people creating them rarely know exactly what they’re going to become.

 

If you want to learn more about effectuation theory, here are a few suggested resources:

 

Realated Research Recaps:

More Research Recaps:

Entrepreneurship education research review illustration

Untangling the Threads of Entrepreneurship Education Research

By reviewing over 150 studies, this influential paper brought clarity to the messy world of entrepreneurship education research — showing that how we teach matters ...
Investors reviewing startup pitches — gender bias in funding

Gender Bias in Entrepreneurial Funding

Women entrepreneurs face stricter investor scrutiny and receive less funding than men, but new research shows these biases can shift, offering hope for change in ...
Students learning entrepreneurship skills to improve employability

Employability and Entrepreneurship Education

Entrepreneurship education doesn’t just prepare students to start businesses — it also makes them more employable by teaching adaptability, problem-solving, and resilience.
Students reflecting during entrepreneurship assessment workshop at Karolinska Institute

Measuring What Matters

Entrepreneurship education has long measured success by counting new ventures or business plans. This study shows how assessment can instead reveal how students actually develop ...
Angel investment in entrepreneurship – funding and mentorship illustration

When Funding Comes with Strings Attached

Angel investments can supercharge your startup with funding, mentorship, and networks – but often at the cost of some autonomy. Striking the right balance between ...
It’s not risky if you know what you’re doing — digital financial literacy and entrepreneurial risk

It’s not risky if you know what you’re doing

Students who feel more financially capable also feel more entrepreneurial, suggesting that the issue may not be a lack of willingness to take risks, but ...
Female role models in entrepreneurship education – Research Recap illustration Students gaining entrepreneurial confidence through female role models Abstract illustration of women students seeing entrepreneurship as attainable

The Role Model Effect Is Real

Female role models can raise entrepreneurial confidence and make startup careers feel more attainable for women students in higher education.
Illustration showing entrepreneurs’ values and wellbeing differences between curiosity-driven and status-driven founders.

Do What You Love!
But Only for the Right Reasons

When your motivation comes from curiosity and freedom, entrepreneurship boosts your wellbeing. But when it’s driven by money or status, it can quietly make you ...
Research recap – relevance in entrepreneurship education (illustration)

Relevance Isn’t a Bonus
– It’s the Point

Most entrepreneurship research is designed to impress reviewers, not to help entrepreneurs. This paper argues that studies should be built with real-world relevance in mind ...
Entrepreneurship education research made clear — Research Recap

A Choice for Clarity

The "Research Recap" by SSES aims to identify and distill high-quality social science research on entrepreneurship education into engaging, accessible narratives, bridging the gap between ...